On this page · 5 sections
Inset vs Overlay Cabinet Doors
What the customer sees, and what it costs you to build
CabinetBuilder.ai · Updated · 7 min read
The door style is the first thing a customer notices and one of the biggest swings in shop time. Inset and overlay can look similar in a rendering. In the shop they are very different jobs.
Overlay doors
An overlay door sits in front of the cabinet opening.
- Partial (standard) overlay on a face frame leaves a band of frame showing around each door.
- Full overlay covers nearly all of the frame or box edge, leaving only a small gap between neighbouring doors. Frameless cabinets almost always use full overlay.
Overlay is forgiving. A door that is slightly out of square, or a box that racks a little on install, still looks right because the door hides the edge behind it. Cup hinges adjust in three directions, so a few minutes with a screwdriver fixes most gaps.
Inset doors
An inset door sits inside the opening, flush with the face frame (or the box edge on a frameless inset). The gap around the door, the reveal, is the whole look, so it has to be even on all four sides. Shops often aim for a reveal around 3/32″ or 1/8″.
That evenness is what costs time. The opening has to be square, the door has to be sized to the opening rather than to a nominal size, and each door is usually fit by hand. Solid-wood doors move with the seasons, so the reveal has to leave room for that. Hinges are either butt hinges mortised into the frame or cup hinges made for inset.
What changes in the price
Inset costs more because it takes more hours, not because it uses more material. Price it from those hours.
- Fitting time per door and drawer front. Count fronts, not cabinets.
- Hinges. Inset hinges and mortised butts usually cost more than standard overlay cup hinges.
- Face frames. Traditional inset needs a face frame, which adds solid-wood parts. See face-frame vs frameless.
- Install. Inset boxes have to go in plumb and square, or the reveals show it.
A flat inset upcharge per kitchen undercharges big kitchens and overcharges small ones. A per-front fitting allowance tracks the work. See how to price a cabinet job.
Which to recommend
Recommend overlay to customers who want a clean modern look, a tighter budget or a faster schedule. Recommend inset to customers who want the furniture look and will pay for the fitting. Show them both: a rendering of each on their own layout ends most debates.
See an inset job
The inset kitchen example is face-frame inset with a 3/32″ reveal. Open its elevations, sheet layouts and cut list to see what the shop gets for an inset job.